District of Columbia
Court of Appeals
Appellate E-Filing System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Information: 19-AA-0294
Short Caption:GARY YOUNGBLOOD, ET AL V. D.C. BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENTClassification:Agency - Administrative Agency - Bd Of Zoning Adjustment (BZA)
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:BZA19689Filed Date:04/08/2019
Opening Event Date:04/08/2019Case Status:Decided/Dismissed
Record Completed:05/03/2019Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:11/13/2019
Argued/Submitted:09/17/2020
Disposition:Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:12/17/2021

Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameIFPAttorney(s)Arguing AttorneyE-Filer
IntervenorMIC9 Owner, LLC on behalf of Meridian International CenterN
Deborah B. BaumYY
PetitionerGary YoungbloodN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerRobert BruceN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerPhyllis Wells BlairN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerLinda HoughtonN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerBasar AkkuzuN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerScott D. ThureenN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerJames Hiscott, Jr.N
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerScott SuchmanN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerDeborah SuchmanN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerLinda RikardN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerJoseph M. PiljayN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerLucy M. JonesN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerVirginia L. MossN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerEvelyn K. MooreN
Heather M. BennoYY
PetitionerJohn D. BekenyN
Heather M. BennoYY
RespondentD.C. Board of Zoning AdjustmentN
Loren L. AliKhanNY
Richard S. LoveNY

Events
Event DateStatusDescriptionResultPDF
04/08/2019FiledPetition For Review
04/08/2019FiledFiling Fee Paid
04/11/2019FiledService Of Petition On Agency/Bd
04/19/2019FiledOrder - Referred to Mediation
04/30/2019FiledScreened Out
05/01/2019FiledInitial Order - directing record
05/01/2019FiledNotice Of Intent To Intervene (Intervenor)
05/03/2019FiledRecord On Appeal
05/03/2019FiledSupplemental Record #1 ( 6/13/18, 4/18/18, 3/28/18, 6/25/18, 5/16/18 hearings)
05/03/2019FiledRecord Completed
05/13/2019FiledBriefing Order
06/24/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)Granted
06/27/2019FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix - 7/8/19
07/05/2019FiledMotion For Summary Reversal (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)Denied
07/10/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File a Response to motion for Summary Reversal (Intervenor, Respondent)Granted
07/15/2019FiledTMC
07/31/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File response to intervenor/respondent's motion for summary affirmance (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Suchman, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)Granted
08/01/2019FiledORDER GRANTING petitioners' motion to extend time to file a response no later than August 7, 2019
08/07/2019FiledResponse to intervenor/respondent's opposition petitioner's motion for reversal and response to intervenor/respondent's motion for summary affirmance (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Suchman, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)
09/04/2019FiledStatement in response to petitioner's motion for summary reversal (Respondent)
09/04/2019FiledOpposition and Cross Motion For Dismissal or For Summary Affirmance (Intervenor)Denied Without Prejudice
09/04/2019FiledORDER GRANTING the motion for extension of time to file the lodged pleadings... F/O DENYING w/o prejudice intervenor's motion to dismiss the petition... F/O DENYING petitioners' motion for summary reversal... F/O DENYING w/o prejudice intervenor's motion or summary affirmance... F/O DIRECTING petitioners to file the consolidated brief and appendix within 30 days
10/03/2019FiledAppearance of Heather Benno (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)
10/03/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)Granted
10/10/2019FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioners - 10/18/19
10/18/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Youngblood)Granted
10/24/2019FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Youngblood)
10/24/2019FiledBrief (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Suchman, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)
10/24/2019FiledJoint Appendix (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Suchman, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)
11/12/2019FiledBrief (Intervenor)
11/13/2019FiledMemorandum/Statement In Lieu Of Brief (Respondent)
11/13/2019FiledBriefing Completed
12/03/2019FiledReply Brief (Petitioner Akkuzu, Petitioner Bekeny, Petitioner Blair, Petitioner Bruce, Petitioner Hiscott, Petitioner Houghton, Petitioner Jones, Petitioner Moore, Petitioner Moss, Petitioner Piljay, Petitioner Rikard, Petitioner Suchman, Petitioner Thureen, Petitioner Youngblood)
01/27/2020FiledACTION - Ready for Calendaring - Regular
07/31/2020FiledACTION - Calendar notice sent
09/17/2020FiledArgued Before Associate Judge McLeese, Associate Judge Deahl, and Senior Judge Nebeker (Heather M. Benno, Esq.) (Deborah B. Baum, Esq.)
10/28/2021FiledVacated And Remanded by Opinion
11/12/2021FiledPetition For Rehearing/Rehearing En Banc (Intervenor)Denied
12/09/2021FiledOrder Denying Intervenor's petition for rehearing and rehearing en banc.
12/17/2021FiledMandate