District of Columbia
Court of Appeals
Appellate E-Filing System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Information: 20-AA-0445
Short Caption:MELINDA ROTH, ET AL. V. D.C. BOARD OF ZONING ADJUSTMENTClassification:Agency - Administrative Agency - Bd Of Zoning Adjustment (BZA)
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:BZA20135Filed Date:07/15/2020
Opening Event Date:07/15/2020Case Status:Decided/Dismissed
Record Completed:08/14/2020Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:11/23/2020
Argued/Submitted:11/16/2021
Disposition:Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:09/02/2022

Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameIFPAttorney(s)Arguing AttorneyE-Filer
Intervenor3428 O Street LLCN
Philip T. EvansNY
Cynthia A. GierhartYY
IntervenorCall Your Mother DeliN
Philip T. EvansNY
Cynthia A. GierhartYY
PetitionerMelinda RothNPro SeY
PetitionerEmma AllmondNPro SeN
PetitionerSam BrumbaughNPro SeN
PetitionerVinod BusjeetNPro SeN
PetitionerMarie-Louise CaravattiNPro SeN
PetitionerJulian Latimer-ClarkeNPro SeN
PetitionerKaren CruseNPro SeN
PetitionerHelen DuBoisNPro SeN
PetitionerCaroline EmadNPro SeN
PetitionerNabil EmadNPro SeN
PetitionerSharon HellmanNPro SeN
PetitionerDenzil MartinNPro SeN
PetitionerChristian NeeleyNPro SeN
PetitionerKimberly PanozzoNPro SeN
PetitionerMichael SavageNPro SeN
PetitionerBen SniderNPro SeN
RespondentD.C. Board of Zoning AdjustmentN
Carl J. SchifferleNY
Caroline Van ZileNY

Events
Event DateStatusDescriptionResultPDF
07/15/2020FiledPetition For Review
07/15/2020FiledFiling Fee Paid
07/16/2020FiledService Of Petition On Agency/Bd
07/24/2020FiledOrder Sua Sponte that the petition for review shall be referred to the mediation coordinator for mediation screening; directing petitioner Roth provide court co-petitioners mailing addresses
07/24/2020FiledReferred to Mediation
08/04/2020FiledScreened Out
08/05/2020FiledInitial Order - Directing Administrative Record; directing petitioner Roth provide court co-petitioners mailing addresses
08/10/2020FiledResponse to July 24, 2020 order (Petitioner Roth)
08/13/2020FiledRecord On Appeal
08/14/2020FiledRecord Completed
08/18/2020FiledBriefing Order
09/08/2020FiledReceived - 9/8/20 - Returned order dated 8/18/20 from USPS stating return to sender-attempted - not known (Petitioner Caroline Emad)
09/08/2020FiledReceived - 9/8/20 - Returned order dated 8/18/20 from USPS stating return to sender-attempted - not known (Petitioner Nabil Emad)
09/09/2020FiledStatement Of Issues (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
09/24/2020FiledMotion for Leave to Intervene (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)Granted
09/25/2020FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)Granted
09/25/2020FiledOpposition to the motion for leave to intervene (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
09/30/2020FiledReply in support of the motion to intervene (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)
10/07/2020FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioners) & Granting Motion for Leave to Intervene (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)
10/13/2020FiledAppendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
10/13/2020FiledAppendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
10/13/2020FiledAppendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
10/13/2020FiledAppendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
10/13/2020FiledAppendix (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
10/14/2020FiledAppearance by Cynthia Gierhart (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)
10/15/2020FiledMotion For Leave to File Brief (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)Granted
10/30/2020FiledOrder Granting Motion For Leave to File Brief (Petitioners)
10/30/2020FiledBrief (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
11/12/2020FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)Granted
11/16/2020FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Respondent)Granted
11/19/2020FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Respondent)
11/23/2020FiledBriefing Completed
11/23/2020FiledBrief (Intervenor 3428 O Street LLC, Intervenor Call Your Mother Deli)
11/23/2020FiledMemorandum/Statement In Lieu Of Brief (Respondent)
12/14/2020FiledReply Brief (Petitioner Allmond, Petitioner Brumbaugh, Petitioner Busjeet, Petitioner Caravatti, Petitioner Cruse, Petitioner DuBois, Petitioner Emad, Petitioner Hellman, Petitioner Latimer-Clarke, Petitioner Martin, Petitioner Neeley, Petitioner Panozzo, Petitioner Roth, Petitioner Savage, Petitioner Snider)
08/06/2021FiledACTION - Ready for Calendaring - Regular
09/29/2021FiledACTION - Calendar notice sent
10/25/2021FiledOrder Sua Sponte rescheduling oral argument
11/16/2021FiledArgued Before Chief Judge Blackburne-Rigsby, and Associate Judges Mcleese, and Deahl,( Melinda Roth Pro Se for the petitioner) (Kimberly Panozzo Pro Se for the petitioner) (Cynthia A. Giehart Esq,. for the intervenor)
08/11/2022FiledVacated And Remanded by Opinion
09/02/2022FiledMandate