District of Columbia
Court of Appeals
Appellate E-Filing System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Information: 17-AA-0554
Short Caption:RYAN CUMMINS V. D.C. ZONING COMMISSIONClassification:Agency - Administrative Agency - Zoning Commission
Lead:17-AA-0554Consolidated:17-AA-0555, 17-AA-0556
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:ZC16-11Filed Date:05/30/2017

Opening Event Date:05/30/2017Case Status:Decided/Dismissed
Record Completed:07/10/2017Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:06/06/2018
Argued/Submitted:02/14/2019
Disposition:Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:07/17/2020

Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameIFPAttorney(s)Arguing AttorneyE-Filer
Amicus CuriaeD.C. Appleseed Center for Law and JusticeN
Marcus GadsonNY
Henry J. Brothers, IIYY
Intervenor-RespondentPark View Community PartnersN
Kristina CrooksNY
Paul J. KiernanYY
PetitionerRyan CumminsNPro SeN
RespondentD.C. Zoning CommissionN
Loren L. AliKhanNY
Richard S. LoveNY

Events
Event DateStatusDescriptionResultPDF
05/30/2017FiledPetition For Review
05/30/2017FiledFiling Fee Paid
06/06/2017FiledService Of Petition On Agency/Bd
06/12/2017FiledNotice Of Intent To Intervene (Intervenor)
06/16/2017FiledOrder Sua Sponte Consolidating Appeals 17-AA-553 through 17-AA-556
06/29/2017FiledResponse to Court's Order dated June 16,2017 (Petitioner Bobeck)
06/29/2017FiledMotion for Leave to Intervene (Intervenor-Petitioner Piatetsky)Denied
06/29/2017FiledResponse to Court's Order dated June 16,2017 (Petitioner Chaudhary)
06/29/2017FiledResponse to Court's Order dated June 16,2017 (Petitioner Cummins)
06/29/2017FiledResponse to Court's Order dated June 16,2017 (Petitioner Poe)
07/03/2017FiledRecord On Appeal (FOR ALL CASES)
07/10/2017FiledRecord Completed
07/11/2017FiledOpposition to motion for leave to intervene (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
07/18/2017FiledReply to Intervenor (Park View Community Partners) opposition to motion to intervene (Intervenor Piatetsky)
07/31/2017FiledBriefing Order & Denied Motion for Leave to Intervene (Intervenor-Petitioner Piatetsky)
07/31/2017FiledAppearance by Philip Evans (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
09/05/2017FiledMotion For Summary Reversal (Petitioner Poe)Denied
09/06/2017FiledTMC
09/13/2017FiledOpposition to petitioner's motion for summary reversal (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
09/14/2017FiledStatement of respondent in response to petitioner's motion for summary reversal (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
09/18/2017FiledOpposition to the motion for summary reversal of zoning commission order No. 16-11 (Petitioner Poe)
10/06/2017FiledMotion For Summary Reversal (Petitioner Bobeck)Denied
10/18/2017FiledOpposition to petitioner's motion for summary reversal and opposed motion to set briefing schedule. (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
10/19/2017FiledResponse to motion for summary reversal and motion to set briefing schedule. (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
10/27/2017FiledReply to intervenor's opposition to motion for summary reversal (Petitioner Cummins)
11/02/2017FiledReply in support its opposed motion to set briefing schedule. (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
11/07/2017FiledMotion For Leave to File amended reply in support of the opposed motion to set briefing schedule (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)Granted
11/13/2017FiledAmended Reply in support of its opposed motion to set briefing schedule (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
11/13/2017FiledORDER GRANTING intervenor's motion to file lodged amended reply and F/O DENYING motions for summary reversal and GRANTING intervenor's motion to set a briefing schedule and F/O DIRECTING petitioners to file the briefs and appendices by DECEMBER 13, 2017...
11/28/2017FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
12/05/2017FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck) - 1/2/18
01/02/2018FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
01/02/2018FiledResponse to second motion to extend the briefing deadline. (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
01/09/2018FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
01/10/2018FiledOpposition to petitioner's (Bobeck) third motion for extension of time to file brief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
01/23/2018FiledMotion To Dismiss Appeal (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)Denied
01/25/2018FiledOpposition to motion to dismiss. (Petitioner Bobeck)
01/29/2018FiledMotion For Leave to File amended or substitute reply in opposition to intervenor's motion to dismiss appeal (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
01/29/2018FiledReply in support of intervenor's motion to dismiss (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
02/01/2018FiledCounsel's Motion to Withdraw (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)Granted
02/14/2018FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck), Motion For Leave to File amended or substitute reply in opposition to intervenor's motion to dismiss appeal (Petitioner Bobeck) & Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
02/14/2018FiledAmended or Substitute Reply in opposition to intervenor's motion to dismiss (Petitioner Bobeck)
02/26/2018FiledJoint Motion For Leave to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
03/14/2018FiledOrder Granting Joint Motion For Leave to File Brief, Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)
03/14/2018FiledJoint Brief (Petitioner Bobeck)
03/14/2018FiledJoint Appendix (Petitioner Bobeck)
03/28/2018FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)Granted
03/29/2018FiledAppearance Paul J. Kiernan, Esq. (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
04/10/2018FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners) - 4/17/18
04/13/2018FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)Granted
04/26/2018FiledOrder Granting Motion For Extension Of Time to File Brief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners) - 5/1/18 & directing motion & brief (Respondent)
05/01/2018FiledBrief (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
05/01/2018FiledSupplemental Appendix (Intervenor Park View Community Partners)
05/07/2018FiledMotion For Leave to File Brief (Amicus Curiae D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice)Granted
05/16/2018FiledMotion For Leave to File Brief (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)Granted
05/21/2018FiledOpposition to motion for leave to file an amicus curiae brief in support of respondent D.C. Zoning Commission (Petitioner Chaudhary)
05/21/2018FiledOpposition to motion for leave to file an amicus curiae brief in support of respondent DC Zoning Commission (Petitioner Cummins)
05/22/2018FiledTMC
05/23/2018FiledJoint Reply in support of motion for leave to file its brief out of time (Petitioner Bobeck)
06/06/2018FiledORDER GRANTING D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice, Enterprise Partners, D.C. Fiscal Policy Institutes, Coalitioin for Smarter Growth, and the Park Morton Residents' Counsel's motion to file the lodged AMICUS BRIEF in support of respondent...F/O GRANTING respondent's motion to file the lodged brief... F/O GRANTING petitioner's motion for an extension of time to file their joint reply brief no later than June 29, 2018
06/06/2018FiledBrief (Amicus Curiae D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice)
06/06/2018FiledBrief (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
06/06/2018FiledBriefing Completed
07/06/2018FiledMotion For Leave to File Reply Brief (Petitioner Poe)Granted
07/20/2018FiledOrder Granting Motion For Leave to File Reply Brief (Petitioner Poe)
07/20/2018FiledReply Brief (Petitioner Poe)
08/02/2018FiledACTION - Ready for Calendaring - Regular
09/28/2018FiledMotion For Leave to participate in oral argument in support of respondent D.C. Zoning Commison (Amicus Curiae D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice)Granted
12/20/2018FiledACTION - Calendar notice sent
12/28/2018FiledMotion To Dismiss Appeal (Petitioner Bobeck)Granted
01/02/2019FiledConsent to motion to dismiss appeal in 17-AA-553 only (Amicus-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
01/03/2019FiledOrder Granting petitioner David Bobeck's motion to withdraw and dismiss appeal.
02/01/2019FiledOrder Granting Amicus Curiae D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice's Motion For Leave to participate in oral argument.
02/06/2019FiledAppearance of Henry J Brothers II (Amicus Curiae D.C. Appleseed Center for Law and Justice)
02/07/2019FiledResponse to Order dated February 1, 2019 (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
02/14/2019FiledArgued Before Judge Thompson, Associate Judge Easterly, Associate Judge McLeese, (Henry J. Brother, II, Esq.) (Richard S. Love, Esq.) (Paul J. Kierman, Esq.) (Marc Anthony Poe, Pro Se) (Ryan Cummins, Pro Se) (Nida Chaudhary, Pro Se)
02/22/2019FiledRule 28(k) Citation Of Supplemental Authority (Amicus-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
07/08/2019FiledRule 28(k) Citation Of Supplemental Authority (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
07/29/2019FiledLetter in response to July 8, 2019 Rule 28(k) letter (Petitioner Poe)
07/30/2019FiledOrder Sua Sponte directing supplemental briefs.
08/30/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Amicus-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
08/30/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Petitioner Poe)
08/30/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Petitioner Cummins)
08/30/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
09/11/2019FiledOrder Sua Sponte directing supplemental briefing.
10/11/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File supplemental brief (Petitioner Poe)Granted
10/11/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Intervenor-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
10/25/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
11/07/2019FiledMemorandum/Statement In Lieu Of Brief (Respondent D.C. Zoning Commission)
11/21/2019FiledOrder Granting petitioner Poe's motion to file supplemental brief.
11/21/2019FiledSupplemental Brief (Petitioner Poe)
12/06/2019FiledMotion For Extension Of Time to File Supplemental Reply Brief (Petitioner Poe)Granted
12/09/2019FiledOpposition to motion for extension of time to file supplemental reply brief (Intervenor-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
12/10/2019FiledOrder Granting petitioners' motion for extension of time to file supplemental reply briefs.
12/17/2019FiledReply to supplemental brief (Petitioner Poe)
06/25/2020FiledVacated And Remanded by OPINION
07/17/2020FiledMandate
07/30/2020FiledMotion To Recall The Mandate (Petitioner Cummins, Chaudhary)Denied
08/03/2020FiledTMC
08/04/2020FiledOpposition to motion to recall the mandate (Intervenor-Respondent Park View Community Partners)
08/06/2020FiledORDER DENYING motion to recall mandate...