District of Columbia
Court of Appeals
Appellate E-Filing System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Information: 19-CV-0332
Short Caption:1305 RHODE ISLAND AVENUE NW, LLC V. JOHN D. MUSSELLS, ET AL.Classification:Appeals - Civil - General Civil (CAB)
Lead:19-CV-0332Consolidated:19-CV-0442
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:2016-CA-008570-BFiled Date:04/17/2019
Opening Event Date:04/17/2019Case Status:Decided/Dismissed
Record Completed:07/22/2019Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:10/03/2019
Argued/Submitted:06/11/2020
Disposition:Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:05/08/2023

Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameIFPAttorney(s)Arguing AttorneyE-Filer
Appellant1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLCN
Robert C. Gill, IIYY
Kyra A. SmerkanichNY
AppelleeJohn D. MussellsN
Kenneth C. CrickmanYY
AppelleePremila M. MussellsN
Kenneth C. CrickmanYY
AppelleeThe Michael John Furman Living TrustN
Carol S. BlumenthalNY
Kathryn ErklauerYY
AppelleeMichael Jude GrippoN
Carol S. BlumenthalYY
Kathryn ErklauerYY
AppelleeLaurie Ann FurmanN
Carol S. BlumenthalNY
Kathryn ErklauerYY

Events
Event DateStatusDescriptionResultPDF
04/17/2019FiledNotice Of Appeal
04/25/2019FiledRecord Index
05/02/2019FiledOrder Directing Mediation Screening Statement
05/13/2019FiledMediation Screening Statement
05/14/2019FiledReferred to Mediation
05/22/2019FiledMotion To Expedite Appeal (Appellant)Denied
05/28/2019FiledTMC
06/04/2019FiledORDER CONSOLIDATING APPEALS (19CV332 & 19CV442) F/O DENYING appellant's motion for expedited consideration of appeal
06/10/2019FiledRecord Index (19-CV-0442)
06/21/2019FiledScreened Out (19-Cv-332)
07/02/2019FiledOrder Screening Out & Initial Order
07/09/2019FiledStatement Regarding Transcript(s) (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
07/22/2019FiledSupplemental Record #1 (18 page/tape) 1/7/19 proceeding
07/22/2019FiledSupplemental Record #2 (101 pages/Swaringer) 2/26/19 proceeding
07/22/2019FiledSupplemental Record #3 (17 pages/tape) 3/19/19 proceeding
07/22/2019FiledRecord Completed
07/25/2019FiledBriefing Order
09/03/2019FiledAppearance by Kyra A. Smerkanich, Esq (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
09/03/2019FiledBrief (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
09/03/2019FiledJoint Appendix (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
10/03/2019FiledBrief (Appellee Mussells)
10/03/2019FiledBrief (Appellee Furman, Appellee Grippo, Appellee The Michael John Furman Living Trust)
10/03/2019FiledBriefing Completed
10/24/2019FiledReply Brief (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
01/27/2020FiledACTION - Ready for Calendaring - Regular
04/29/2020FiledACTION - Calendar notice sent
06/11/2020FiledArgued Before Associate Judge Glickman, Associate Judge Deahl, Senior Judge Ruiz (Robert C. Gill, II, Esquire) (Kenneth C. Crickman, Esquire)
10/17/2022FiledMotion for ruling on case (Appellee Mussells, Appellee The Michael John Furman Living Trust)Granted
12/02/2022FiledORDER that the Superior Court judgment is reversed and these cases are remanded to the Superior Court.
12/19/2022FiledMotion to clarify or amend order (Appellee The Michael John Furman Living Trust)Granted
12/22/2022FiledAMENDED ORDER that the Superior Court judgment is reversed and these cases are remanded to the Superior Court.
12/27/2022WithdrawnMandate
03/31/2023FiledMotion To Recall The Mandate (Appellee Mussells)Granted
04/03/2023FiledTMC
04/10/2023FiledAppellant's Reponse to Appellees John D. Mussells and Premila M. Mussells' Motion to Recall Mandate (Appellant 1305 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, LLC)
04/12/2023FiledORDER GRANTING appellees' motion to recall the mandate...
04/13/2023FiledReversed And Remanded by MOJ
04/27/2023FiledReversed And Remanded by Opinion
04/27/2023FiledPetition For Rehearing/Rehearing En Banc (Appellee Mussells)Denied
05/08/2023FiledOrder Denying appellees' petition for rehearing or rehearing en banc.
05/08/2023FiledMandate