District of Columbia
Court of Appeals
Appellate E-Filing System
C-Track, the browser based CMS for Appellate Courts
Case Search
Participant Search
Login
Cases
Case Search
Participant Search
Case Information: 23-CV-0700
Short Caption:
MICHAEL PATRICK MURRAY, ET AL. V. MOTOROLA, INC., ET AL.
Classification:
Appeals - Civil - General Civil (CAB)
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:
2001-CA-008479-B
Filed Date:
08/22/2023
Opening Event Date:
08/22/2023
Case Status:
Decided/Dismissed
Record Completed:
12/29/2023
Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:
06/17/2024
Argued/Submitted:
01/14/2025
Disposition:
Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:
09/02/2025
Party Information
Appellate Role
Party Name
IFP
Attorney(s)
Arguing Attorney
E-Filer
Appellant
Michael Patrick Murray
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Cherie Morganroth
N
Y
Michelle A. Parfitt
N
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Gilbert Cochran
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Pamela Cochran
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
David Keller
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Marsha L. Keller
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Patricia A. Murray
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Dino Schofield
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Eret Schwamb
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Richard Schwamb
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Baldassare Agro
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Debrah A. Agro
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Bret Kenyon Bocook
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Alan Marks
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Shawn Kidd
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Cristina Prischman
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Mindy Brown
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Monique Solomon
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Robert Noroski
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Laura Lynn Bocook
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Ellen Marks
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Aisha Kidd
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellant
Andrew Solomon
N
James F. Green
N
Y
Jeffrey B. Morganroth
Y
Y
Kristie M. Hightower
N
Y
Rudie R. Soileau Jr.
N
Y
Steven R. Hickman
N
Y
Hunter W. Lundy
N
Y
Victor H. Pribanic
N
Y
Mayer Morganroth
N
Y
Appellee
Motorola, Inc.
N
Rand Brothers
N
Y
Terrence Dee
Y
Y
Linda Coberly
N
Y
Appellee
Audiovox Communications Corporation
N
Matthew D. Berkowitz
N
Y
Paul J. Maloney
N
Y
Kelly Cousoulis
N
Y
Appellee
Cellular One Group
N
Carrie G. Amezcua
N
Y
Andrew G. Hope
N
Y
Howard D. Scher
N
Y
Appellee
Cellular Telecommunications & Internet Association
N
Michael McNeely
N
Y
Vicki L. Dexter
N
Y
Appellee
Cricket Wireless, LLC
N
Eric Leppo
N
Y
Richard J. Medoff
N
Y
Appellee
United States Cellular Corporation
N
Eugene A. Schoon
N
Y
Frank R. Volpe
N
Y
Elizabeth M. Chiarello
N
Y
Appellee
T-Mobile USA, Inc.
N
Mary Rose Hughes
N
Y
Daniel P. Ridlon
N
Y
Steven Y. Koh
N
Y
Appellee
Telecommunications Industry Association
N
Renee B. Appel
N
Y
Sarah Chemli
N
Y
Appellee
Sprint Nextel Corporation f/k/a Nextel Communications
N
Shannon Schoultz
N
Y
Charles C. Eblen
N
Y
Appellee
Sprint Spectrum, L.P. d/b/a Sprint PCS
N
Shannon Schoultz
N
Y
Charles C. Eblen
N
Y
Appellee
Samsung Electronics America, Inc., the successor by merger to Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC
N
Jaime W. Luse
N
Y
Jung Yong Lee
N
Y
Appellee
Qualcomm Inc.
N
Stephen T. Fowler
N
Y
Frank Citera
N
Y
Appellee
Sony Electronics, Inc.
N
Stephen T. Fowler
N
Y
Frank Citera
N
Y
Appellee
LG Electronics MobileComm U.S.A., Inc.
N
Sean M. Reilly
N
Y
Appellee
Microsoft Mobile Oy
N
Richard W. Stimson
N
Y
Erica Franzetti
N
Y
Lohr Beck
N
Y
Mike Stenglein
N
Y
Lauren N. Smith
N
Y
Appellee
AT&T, Inc.
N
Curtis S. Renner
N
Y
Thomas C. Watson
N
Y
Anthony T. Pierce
N
Y
Appellee
Cingular Wireless LLC
N
Curtis S. Renner
N
Y
Thomas C. Watson
N
Y
Anthony T. Pierce
N
Y
Appellee
AT&T Wireless Services Inc.
N
Curtis S. Renner
N
Y
Thomas C. Watson
N
Y
Anthony T. Pierce
N
Y
Appellee
Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Bell Atlantic Mobile, Inc.
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Verizon Wireless, Inc.
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Verizon Wireless Personal Communications LP f/k/a Primeco Personal Communications LP
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Verizon Communications Inc.
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Western Wireless LLC f/k/a Western Wireless Corporation
N
Kelley Connolly Barnaby
N
Y
David Venderbush
N
Y
Scott Elder
N
Y
Appellee
Motorola Mobility, LLC
N
Rand Brothers
N
Y
Terrence Dee
Y
Y
Dion J. Robbins
N
Y
Appellee
Motorola Solutions, Inc.
N
Rand Brothers
N
Y
Terrence Dee
Y
Y
Dion J. Robbins
N
Y
Linda Coberly
N
Y
Events
Event Date
Status
Description
Result
PDF
08/22/2023
Filed
Notice Of Appeal
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #1 (89-pages/ Armstrong) 12/12/16 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #2 (209 pages/Price) 11/2/18 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #3 (105 pages/Davis) 9/12/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #4 (81 pages/Clark) 9/12/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #5 (90 pages/Clark) 9/13/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #6 (90 pages/Davis) 9/13/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #7 (84 pages/Davis) 9/14/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #8 (74 page/Clark) 9/14/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #9 (96 pages/Clark) 9/15/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #10 (51 pages/Davis) 9/15/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #11 (14 pages/Davis) 9/19/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #12 (78 pages/Clark) 9/20/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #13 (74 pages/Davis) 9/20/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #14 (107 pages/Clark) 9/21/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #15 (95 pages/Clark) 9/21/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #16 (138 pages/Clark) 9/22/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #17 (96 pages/Davis) 9/27/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #18 (133 pages/Clark) 9/27/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #19 (94 pages/Clark) 9/28/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #20 (89 pages/Davis) 9/28/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #21 (108 pages/Davis) 9/29/22 proceeding
09/07/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #22 (96 pages/Clark) 9/29/22 proceeding
09/12/2023
Filed
Order Sua Sponte that this appeal shall be referred to the mediation coordinator for mediation screening & Order that appellee HTC, America, Inc., shall advise this court as to the identity of its counsel within 30 days from the date of the order & Ordered that counsel for all parties shall register, if not already registered for the court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
09/12/2023
Filed
Referred to Mediation
09/27/2023
Filed
Appearance of Mary Rose Hughes, Esq. (Appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
10/03/2023
Filed
Appearance by Stephen T. Fowler, Esq. (Appellee Qualcomm Inc., Appellee Sony Electronics, Inc.)
10/05/2023
Filed
Supplemental Record #23 (18 Pages/ Tape) 1/6/2023 proceeding
10/10/2023
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
Granted
10/23/2023
Filed
Order that the motion is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Daniel P. Ridlon, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc. F/O that counsel for all parties shall register, if not already registered, for the court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
11/06/2023
Filed
Received returned mail court's order dated 10/23/23, mailed copy to appellant's counsel James Green & Michelle Parfitt to the most recent address of record on the docket and returned by U.S.P.S. as undeliverable and forwarded to the file room. (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
11/13/2023
Filed
Appearance by Kelley Connolly Barnaby (Appellee Bell Atlantic Mobile, Inc., Appellee Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, Appellee Verizon Communications Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Personal Communications LP f/k/a Primeco Personal Communications LP, Appellee Western Wireless LLC f/k/a Western Wireless Corporation)
12/12/2023
Filed
Received returned mail court's order dated 10/23/23, mailed copy to appellee counsel John Korns to the most recent address of record on the docket and returned by U.S.P.S. as undeliverable and forwarded to the file room. (Appellee Cellular One Group)
12/12/2023
Filed
Screened Out
12/20/2023
Filed
Appearance by Jaime W. Luse, Esq. (Appellee Samsung Electronics America, Inc., the successor by merger to Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC)
12/27/2023
Filed
Order Screening Out & Initial Order
12/28/2023
Filed
Record Index
12/29/2023
Filed
Record Completed
01/03/2024
Filed
Briefing Order
01/04/2024
Filed
Appearance by Rand Brothers, Esq. (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
01/04/2024
Filed
Appearance by Jeffrey D. Skinner, Esq. (Appellee Apple Inc.)
01/05/2024
Filed
Appearance by Sean M. Reilly, Esq. (Appellee LG Electronics MobileComm U.S.A., Inc)
01/08/2024
Filed
Appearance by Matthew M. Wright (Appellee HTC America, Inc.)
01/08/2024
Filed
Notice Received from appellee advising the court the death of attorney Ardrelle M. Bahar (Appellee Telecommunications Industry Association)
01/09/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Bell Atlantic Mobile, Inc., Appellee Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, Appellee Verizon Communications Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Personal Communications LP f/k/a Primeco Personal Communications LP, Appellee Western Wireless LLC f/k/a Western Wireless Corporation)
Granted
01/09/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Bell Atlantic Mobile, Inc., Appellee Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, Appellee Verizon Communications Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Inc., Appellee Verizon Wireless Personal Communications LP f/k/a Primeco Personal Communications LP, Appellee Western Wireless LLC f/k/a Western Wireless Corporation)
Granted
01/09/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee United States Cellular Corporation)
Granted
01/10/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
Granted
01/10/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
Granted
01/10/2024
Filed
Appearance by Frank R. Volpe (Appellee United States Cellular Corporation)
01/10/2024
Filed
Appearance by Carrie G. Amezcua (Appellee Cellular One Group)
01/10/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
Granted
01/23/2024
Filed
Order Granting that the motions of Kelley C. Barnaby, Esquire are granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of David Venderbush, Esquire and Scott Elder, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellees Bell Atlantic Mobile, Inc., Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless, Verizon Communications Inc., Verizon Wireless Inc., Verizon Wireless Personal Communications LP f/k/a Primeco Personal Communications LP, and Western Wireless LLC f/k/a Western Wireless Corporation. F/O that the motion of Frank R. Volpe, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Elizabeth M. Chiarello, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellee United States Cellular Corporation. F/O that the motions of Rand Brothers, Esquire are granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of Terrence Dee, Esquire, Sarah Krajewski, Esquire and Dion J. Robbins, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellees Motorola Mobility, LLC and Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc. F/O that David Venderbush, Esquire, Scott Elder, Esquire, Elizabeth M. Chiarello, Esquire, Terrence Dee, Esquire, Sarah Krajewski, Esquire, and Dion J. Robbins, Esquire shall register for the court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
01/23/2024
Filed
Received - this court's order date 12/27/23 mailed to Michael McNeely at 3706 Huntington Street, NW Washington DC 20015 and returned by U.S.P.S. this date as undeliverable (Appellee Cellular Telecommunications & Internet Association)
02/13/2024
Filed
Motion For Leave to File Brief, Appendix (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
02/20/2024
Filed
Appearance by Jung Yong Lee, Esq. (Appellee Samsung Electronics America, Inc., the successor by merger to Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC)
02/26/2024
Filed
Order that appellants' motion is granted and appellant's lodged brief and appendix are filed. F/O that appellees' briefs shall be filed on or before March 22, 2024.
02/26/2024
Filed
Brief (Redacted) (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
02/26/2024
Filed
Appendix (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
02/29/2024
Filed
Corporate Disclosure Statement (Appellee Qualcomm Inc.)
02/29/2024
Filed
Corporate Disclosure Statement (Appellee Sony Electronics, Inc.)
03/12/2024
Filed
Order dated 12/27/23, mailed to appellee Cellular Telecommunications attorney Michael McNeeley, Esquire at the most current address of record on this court's docket to 3706 Huntington Street, NW, Washington, DC 20015, returned by U.S.P.S. as "undeliverable" and returned to files this date. (Appellee Cellular Telecommunications & Internet Association)
03/13/2024
Filed
Appearance by Eric Leppo, Esq. (Appellee Cricket Wireless, LLC)
03/20/2024
Filed
Appearance by Marcus K. Jones, Esq. (Appellee Cricket Wireless, LLC)
03/20/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
Granted
03/22/2024
Filed
Brief (Redacted) (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc., Appellee Motorola, Inc.)
04/02/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Redacted) (Appellee Cellular Telecommunications & Internet Association)
Granted
04/11/2024
Filed
Change Of Address Received of Eugene Schoon
04/12/2024
Filed
Order that the motion of Rand Brothers, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Linda Coberly, Esquire on behalf of appellees Motorola Inc., Motorola Mobility, LLC and Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc. & Order that the motion of Michael D. McNeely, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Vicki L. Dexter, Esquire on behalf of appellee Cellular Telecommunication & Internet Association & Order that Hunter W. Lundy, Esquire, Rudie R. Soileau, Jr., Esquire, Kristie M. Hightower, Esquire, Victor H. Pribanic, Esquire, Matthew Doebler, Esquire and Steven R. Hickman, Esquire shall, within 20 days from the date of this order file an application and motion to appear pro hac vice. Failure to comply with this order shall result in appellants' briefs being stricken from the record. & Order that all attorneys that have not previously registered shall register for this court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
04/12/2024
Filed
Reply Brief (Redacted) (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
04/15/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Appellee Samsung Electronics America, Inc., the successor by merger to Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC)
Granted
04/17/2024
Filed
Motion For Leave to File Corrected/Amended Brief (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
04/17/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
04/17/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
04/22/2024
Filed
Received order dated 2/26/24, mailed to James F. Green, Esquire at the most current address of record on this court's docket, and returned as "undeliverable" and forwarded to files this date (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
04/26/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
04/26/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
04/26/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Granted
05/03/2024
Filed
Order Granting that appellee Samsung Electronics America, Inc. f/k/a Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC's motion is granted and the appearance of John B. Isbister is hereby withdrawn as co-counsel of record for appellee. F/O that appellants' motion for leave is granted and the Clerk shall file appellants' lodged corrected/amended brief. F/O that the motions of Jeffrey B. Morganroth are granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of Kristie M. Hightower, Esquire and Rudie R. Soileau, Jr., Esquire, pro hac vice on behalf of appellants. F/O that all counsel who have not previously registered shall register for this court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
05/03/2024
Filed
Amended/Corrected Brief (Redacted) (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
05/07/2024
Filed
Received - Order dated April 12, 2024, mailed to attorney James F. Green, Esquire to 2000 L Street, NW Suite 400, Washington, DC 20036 and returned by U.S.P.S. as "undeliverable" and remailed this date to include the name of the law firm to AshCraft & Gerel 2000 L Street, NW Suite 400, Washington, DC 20036 this date. elp (Appellant Murray)
05/07/2024
Filed
Received - Order dated April 12, 2024, mailed to appellant Michelle A. Parfitt, Esquire to 2000 L Street, NW Suite 400 Washington, DC 20036 and returned by the U.S.P.S. as "undeliverable" and remailed to the current address on the docket Ashcraft & Gerel 1825 K Street, NW Suite 700, Washington DC 20006 (Appellant Murray)
05/22/2024
Filed
Order that the motions of Jeffrey B. Morganroth, Esquire are granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of Steven R. Hickman, Esquire, Hunter W. Lundy, Esquire, and Victor H. Pribanic, Esquire, pro hac vice on behalf of appellants. F/O that Steven R. Hickman, Esquire, Hunter W. Lundy, Esquire and Victor H. Pribanic, Esquire, shall register for this court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith. F/O that all counsel who have not yet registered shall, within 20 days from the date of this order, register for this court's mandatory e-filing.
06/17/2024
Filed
Briefing Completed
07/18/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc.)
Granted
07/22/2024
Filed
Received - Order dated May 22, 2024, mailed to attorney James F. Green, Esquire to AshCraft & Gerel 2000 L Street, NW Suite 400, Washington, DC 20036 this date and returned by U.S.P.S. as "undeliverable". kr (Appellant Murray)
07/30/2024
Filed
Order that the motion of Sarah A. Krajewski, Esquire is granted and her appearance is hereby withdrawn as co-counsel for record for appellees Motorola Inc., Motorola Mobility, LLC, Motorola Solutions,, Inc. f/k/a Motorola Inc. & Order that James F. Green, Esquire, Marcus K. Jones, Esquire, Linda Coberly, Esquire and Vicki L. Dexter, Esquire shall register for mandatory e-filing, see Administrative Order 1-18 or show cause, within 15 days from the date of the order, why they should not be held in contempt for failure to comply with this court's order
08/06/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw Appearance (Appellee Cricket Wireless, LLC)
Granted
08/09/2024
Filed
Notice by James F. Green, Esquire of Registration for Mandatory E-Filing (Appellant Murray)
08/12/2024
Filed
Received - Order dated 7/30/24, mailed to attorney James F. Green, Esquire to 2000 L Street, NW , Suite 400, Washington Dc 20036 returned by U.S.P.S. as "undeliverable" and remailed to his most current address on the court docket to 1825 K Street, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20006 (Appellant Murray)
08/13/2024
Filed
ACTION - Ready for Calendaring - Regular
08/21/2024
Filed
Order that Seamus C. Duffy, Esquire, Mike Stenglein, Esquire, Lohr Beck, Esquire, Lauren Smith, Esquire, Francis A. Citera, Esquire, Charlie Eblen, Esquire, Steve Koh, Esquire, Michael Scoville, Esquire, Howard D. Sher, Esquire, Andrew G. Hope, Esquire, and Kelly Consoulis, Esquire, shall within 20 days from the date of this order, file an application and motion to appear pro hac vice. Failure to comply with this order shall result in appellee's brief being stricken from the record.
08/23/2024
Filed
Appearance by Anthony T. Pierce, Esq. (Appellee AT&T Wireless Services Inc., Appellee AT&T Inc., Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC)
08/23/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee AT&T Wireless Services Inc., Appellee AT&T Inc., Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC)
08/26/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Appellee AT&T Wireless Services Inc., Appellee AT&T Inc., Appellee Cingular Wireless LLC)
Granted
08/26/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
08/26/2024
Filed
Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Steve Y. Koh (Redacted) (Appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
Granted
08/26/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Qualcomm Inc., Appellee Sony Electronics, Inc.)
08/26/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Qualcomm Inc., Appellee Sony Electronics, Inc.)
08/26/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Redacted) (Appellee Qualcomm Inc., Appellee Sony Electronics, Inc.)
Granted
08/27/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Redacted) (Appellee T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
Granted
08/27/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy)
08/27/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Redacted) (Appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy)
Granted
08/27/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Redacted) (Appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy)
Granted
09/03/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy)
Granted
09/03/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy)
09/05/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Cellular One Group)
09/05/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Cellular One Group)
Granted
09/05/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Appellee Cellular One Group)
Granted
09/10/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Sprint Spectrum, L.P. d/b/a Sprint PCS, Appellee Sprint Nextel Corporation f/k/a Nextel Communications)
09/10/2024
Filed
Motion To Appear Pro Hac Vice (Redacted) (Appellee Sprint Spectrum, L.P. d/b/a Sprint PCS, Appellee Sprint Nextel Corporation f/k/a Nextel Communications)
Granted
09/13/2024
Filed
Notice of Compliance with the August 21, 2024 Order Received (Appellee Motorola Mobility, LLC, Appellee Motorola Solutions, Inc. f/k/a Motorola, Inc.)
09/16/2024
Filed
Order that the motion of Eric M. Leppo, Esquire granted and the appearance of Marcus K. Jones, Esquire is withdrawn as co-counsel of record for appellee Cricket Wireless, LLC. F/O that the motion of Anthony T. Pierce, Esquire is granted and the appearance of Seamus C. Duffy, Esquire is hereby withdrawn as co-counsel of record for appellees AT&T Inc, Cingular Wireless, LLC and AT&T Wireless Services, Inc. F/O that the motion of Mary Rose Hughes, Esquire to enter the appearance of Steve Y. Koh, Esquire pro hac vice is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Steve Y. Koh, Esquire on behalf of appellee T-Mobile USA Inc. F/O that the motion of Mary Rose Hughes, Esquire to withdraw the appearance of Michael Scoville, Esquire as co-counsel of record for appellee T-Mobile USA Inc. is granted. F/O that the motion of Stephen T. Fowler, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Frank Citera, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellees Qualcomm Inc., and Sony Electronics, Inc. F/O that the motions of Erica Franzetti, Esquire are granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of Lohr Beck, Esquire and Mike Stenglein, Esquire pro hac vice on behalf of appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy. F/O that Steve Y. Koh, Esquire, Frank Citera, Esquire, Lohr Beck, Esquire, and Mike Stenglein, Esquire shall register for the court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
09/19/2024
Filed
Ordered that the motion of Erica Franzetti, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Lauren N. Smith pro hac vice on behalf of appellee Microsoft Mobile Oy. It is Ordered that the motions of Carrie G. Amezcua, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearances of Andrew G. Hope, Esquire and Howard D. Scher pro hac vice on behalf of appellee Cellular One Group. It is Ordered that the motion of Shannon Schoultz, Esquire is granted and the Clerk shall enter the appearance of Charles C. Eblen on behalf of appellees Sprint Nextel Corporation f/k/a/ Nextel Communication and Sprint Spectrum L.P. d/b/a Sprint PCS. It is Ordered that all counsel who have not previously registered shall register for this court's mandatory e-filing pursuant to Administrative Order 1-18 forthwith.
10/02/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee HTC America, Inc.)
10/02/2024
Filed
Counsel's Motion to Withdraw (Redacted) (Appellee HTC America, Inc.)
Granted
10/10/2024
Filed
Motion to Dismiss Apple as an Appellee and Withdraw Notice of Appearance of Jeffrey D. Skinner (Redacted) (Appellee Apple, Inc.)
Granted
10/10/2024
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Apple, Inc.)
10/28/2024
Filed
Order that HTC America Inc.'s motion to withdraw is granted and HTC America Inc., is hereby dismissed as a party to this appeal and the appearance of its counsel Michael Wright is withdrawn & Order that Apple Inc.'s motion is granted and Apple Inc. is hereby dismissed as a party to this appeal and the appearance of its counsel Jeffrey D. Skinner, Esquire is withdrawn & Order that Frank Citera, Esquire and Lauren Smith, Esquire shall immediately register for this court's mandatory e-filing. see Administrative Order 1-18, or show cause, within 15 days from the date of this order, why they should not be held in contempt for failure to comply with this court's order.
11/27/2024
Filed
ACTION - Calendar notice sent
12/13/2024
Filed
Appearance of Renee B. Appel (Appellee Telecommunications Industry Association)
01/10/2025
Filed
Redaction Certificate (Appellee Telecommunications Industry Association)
01/10/2025
Filed
Appearance of Richard J. Medoff (Appellee Cricket Wireless, LLC)
01/10/2025
Filed
Counsel's Motion To Withdraw (Not Including Anders) (Appellee Telecommunications Industry Association)
Granted
01/14/2025
Filed
Argued Before Associate Judge Easterly, Associate Judge Howard, Associate Judge Shanker (Jeffrey B. Morganroth, Esq.) (Terrence Dee, Esq.)
01/21/2025
Filed
Order Granting appellee Telecommunications Industry Association's motion to withdraw the appearance of Thomas T. Locke, Esquire, as counsel of record and the appearance of Thomas T. Locke, Esquire, is hereby withdrawn.
07/07/2025
Filed
Change Of Address Received From Daniel P. Ridlon
07/07/2025
Filed
Change Of Address Received From Steve Y. Koh
07/17/2025
Filed
Affirmed by OPINION.
07/25/2025
Filed
Appearance of Sarah Chemli (Appellee Telecommunications Industry Association)
07/29/2025
Filed
Petition For Rehearing/Rehearing En Banc (Appellant Agro, Appellant Bocook, Appellant Brown, Appellant Cochran, Appellant Keller, Appellant Kidd, Appellant Marks, Appellant Murray, Appellant Noroski, Appellant Prischman, Appellant Schofield, Appellant Schwamb, Appellant Solomon)
Denied
08/21/2025
Filed
Ordered that appellants' petition for rehearing/rehearing en banc is denied.
09/02/2025
Filed
Mandate